Human rights lawyer Femi Falana, SAN, has voiced concerns over the recent announcement by Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Minister Nyesom Wike to provide housing for judges, calling it ethically questionable. In October, Wike revealed plans to build 40 residential quarters for judges in Katampe, Abuja a move that has sparked controversy over the independence of the judiciary.
During an appearance on Channels Television’s Politics Today, Falana argued that judicial independence could be compromised if judges accept gifts from the executive branch, especially when officials in that branch could be subject to legal decisions by the courts. “As FCT Minister, Wike has the powers similar to a state governor but must stay within FCT limits under Section 299 of the Constitution,” Falana remarked. “You cannot offer gifts like houses or cars to judges who may oversee cases involving the executive.”
Falana emphasized that the Nigerian Constitution enshrines financial autonomy for the judiciary to prevent conflicts of interest and maintain its impartiality. He also criticized Wike’s recent demolition activities within the FCT, describing the process as “primitive” and out of alignment with legal standards. According to Falana, the Urban and Regional Planning Act mandates due process, including an appeal process, before any demolitions can proceed.
Responding to Falana’s comments, Wike dismissed concerns about compromising judicial decisions, explaining that the housing initiative originated from President Bola Tinubu. In a media chat, Wikc e larified, “The president approved this as part of the 2024 budget to support judicial independence by providing stable housing for judges.” He emphasized that his role is to carry out an approved project, with full endorsement from the Federal Executive Council.
Wike further defended the housing project, pointing out that judges currently live in rented accommodations in areas with insufficient security. He stated that the new housing project aims to provide safe, stable living conditions for judges, aligning with Tinubu’s commitment to strengthening judicial independence.
